Richards Favorite Videos

The only version to include the melted heart end, and here, they melt into eachother. In this version, the black goblin/jack in the box villain is the king of the toy room. When his advances to the ballerina are rejected and the soldier defends, he prosecutes and has them executed by firing squad into fireplace. Like the russion depiction, the ballerina chooses to die with the brave soldier she loves.
A one-legged tin soldier is cruelly mocked by other toys because of his deformity. The soldier falls in love with a toy ballerina who is desired by the toy king. The king exercises his military power to get the girl for himself. The tale ends tragically, with a surprisingly graphic execution by firing squad. This is probably too violent and weird for little kids. The cartoon itself is very nicely animated, perhaps even moreso than the other Ub Iwerks fairy tales. There are some celebrity caricature toys, including a Groucho Marx jack-in-the-box.

Tin Soldier from Fantasia 2000, but with music from Blink 182 - Miss You

From 1959, Soviet Union. A beautiful adaptation of the Hans Christian Andersen fairytale. It’s the only one that doesn’t replace the Black Goblin character that lives in the cigar box, and keeps the full 3 acts of the story and keeps the tragic ending.

Regrettably though, the best part of the story’s ending is not shown: the next day the maid is cleaning the fireplace and finds the remains. Of the ballerina, only ash, and of the soldier, a lump of tin that had melted in the shame of a heart.

The ending is also changed from the Andersen original in that the paper ballerina is not gusted into the fire by chance, but willingly leaps to her death so she can embrace her love before they both are engulfed by the flames.

I’ve watched the end a hundred times and go back to play it again every once in awhile. It’s just flipping beautiful. His calling out to her while he melts. Her sadness which turns to resolve as she knows the choice she wants to make (very much like the Titanic scene where Rose gives a long stare back at Jack as she is lowered in the lifeboat and decides to jump back onto the sinking ship where they embrace to meet their doom together). Everything about it is great. The cuts back and forth between in the fire and safe on the table. The anguish of the black goblin after she makes her final choice. He loses. But in a way, they all lose.
If only they included the melted heart ending, it would be a 5 star rendition.